Break Fix vs Managed Services: Key Differences

Deciding between managed services and break-fix services can be challenging for many businesses. Managed services provide proactive IT support, with studies from CloudSecureTech showing potential cost reductions of 25-45% and efficiency gains of 45-65%.

However, break-fix services appeal to companies that prefer a pay-as-you-go approach, addressing issues only when they occur offering more control over spending.

Both models have their strengths and limitations. In this blog, we’ll break down the differences between managed services and break-fix services to help you find the ideal solution for your business needs.

What Are Break-Fix Services?

Break-fix services operate on a reactive basis. Essentially, when something breaks, the IT service provider steps in to fix it. This approach means that no ongoing relationship exists between the service provider and the business until a problem arises.

How Break-Fix Services Work

When a technical issue occurs, the business contacts the IT provider, who then diagnoses and resolves the problem. The business is billed for the time and materials needed to fix the issue, with no ongoing fees or contracts involved. This model is often appealing to businesses that prefer to pay only when problems arise rather than commit to a recurring service fee.

What Are Managed Services?

Managed services, on the other hand, offer a proactive approach to IT management, instead of waiting for something to break, a managed service provider (MSP) continuously monitors, maintains, and manages a company’s IT infrastructure. This approach ensures that issues are identified and resolved before they can cause significant disruptions.

This also includes eliminating expensive downtime and helping prevent devastating cyber security breaches that target SMBs – among other benefits.

How Managed Services Work

Managed services are typically offered under a fixed monthly fee, covering a wide range of IT support services. This can include network monitoring, cybersecurity, data backup, and more. The MSP acts as an extension of the business’s IT department, providing ongoing support and strategic guidance.

Transform Your IT into a Value Driver

See how when you work with a leading managed services provider.

Get a Free Consultation

Break Fix vs. Managed Services: Key Differences

1. Cost Structure

One of the most significant differences between break-fix and managed services is the cost structure. Break-fix services involve variable costs, as businesses pay only when an issue arises. However, these costs can be unpredictable and sometimes higher than expected, especially if a major issue occurs.

Managed services, on the other hand, offer a predictable, fixed monthly fee. This allows businesses to budget more effectively and avoid unexpected IT expenses. While the ongoing cost may seem higher at first glance, it often proves more cost-effective in the long run, as it includes preventative maintenance that reduces the likelihood of costly issues.

2. Proactive vs. Reactive Support

Break-fix services are reactive by nature. The provider only steps in when something goes wrong, which means there’s no ongoing monitoring or maintenance. This approach can lead to extended downtime, as problems may not be identified until they become serious.

Managed services provide proactive support with continuous monitoring of your IT systems. The MSP can identify and address potential issues before they escalate, reducing downtime and keeping your business operations running smoothly.

3. Business Continuity

In a break-fix model, business continuity can be at risk. Since the service provider only comes into the picture when a problem occurs, there may be significant delays in getting systems back online. This can lead to extended periods of downtime, which can be costly and damaging to a business.

Managed services prioritize business continuity. With proactive monitoring, regular maintenance, and a team of IT experts on standby, MSPs can ensure that your IT systems are always up and running. This approach minimizes the risk of downtime and keeps your business productive.

More articles you might like:

4. IT Strategy and Planning

Break-fix services focus solely on fixing issues as they arise. There is little to no emphasis on IT strategy, planning, or aligning technology with business goals. This lack of strategic oversight can lead to a piecemeal approach to IT, where systems and technologies are implemented without a long-term vision.

Managed services include strategic IT planning as part of their offering. The MSP works closely with the business to understand its goals and develop an IT strategy that supports those objectives. This includes planning for future growth, implementing new technologies, and ensuring that the IT infrastructure aligns with the overall business strategy.

5. Expertise and Resources

Break-fix providers often operate on a smaller scale, with limited resources and expertise. While they may be capable of resolving basic IT issues, they may not have the specialized knowledge or resources to handle more complex challenges.

Managed service providers typically have a team of IT professionals with a broad range of expertise. This allows them to offer more comprehensive support, from basic troubleshooting to advanced cybersecurity measures. MSPs also have access to the latest tools and technologies, ensuring that your IT systems are always up to date.

Other Break-Fix vs. Managed Services Comparison

Aspect	Break-Fix Services	Managed Services
Scalability	Harder to scale with growing business needs.	Easily scalable with continuous monitoring and adaptable services.
Security	Reactive approach, addressing security issues after they occur.	Proactive threat detection and prevention with continuous monitoring.
Partnership Approach	Transactional, only engaging when issues arise.	Collaborative partnership, aligning IT strategies with business goals.
Proactive Maintenance	None, maintenance only after issues occur.	Regular proactive maintenance to prevent issues before they escalate.
Compliance	No focus on regulatory compliance unless specifically requested.	Ensures ongoing compliance with industry regulations through regular monitoring.
Service Availability	Limited availability, potentially delaying fixes.	24/7 availability with SLAs ensuring quick response and resolution times.
Long-term Value	Short-term fixes may result in long-term inefficiencies and higher costs.	Long-term focus on optimizing IT performance, reducing costs, and boosting value.

Overcoming IT Challenges With ProSource

At ProSource, we understand the critical role that IT plays in your business’s success. Our managed services are designed to provide you with the support and expertise you need to keep your IT systems running smoothly. With a proactive approach, our team continuously monitors and maintains your IT infrastructure, ensuring that potential issues are addressed before they impact your business.

We offer a comprehensive range of managed services, including network monitoring, cybersecurity, data backup, and strategic IT planning. Our solutions are tailored to meet the unique needs of your business, allowing you to focus on what you do best—growing your business.